Recent research has revealed significant concerns about heavy metal contamination in various salt products, particularly challenging the popular perception that pink Himalayan salt is a healthier alternative to regular table salt. A comprehensive examination of the current evidence reveals variable levels of potentially harmful contaminants across different salt types, with some options emerging as safer choices for Australian consumers.
Heavy Metal Presence in Pink Himalayan Salt
A groundbreaking study led by Nutrition Research Australia (NRAUS) evaluated the mineral composition of pink salts available in Australia and found concerning results. The researchers tested 31 samples of pink salts and compared them to a control of iodized white table salt. Using mass spectrometry, they analyzed for a wide range of minerals and heavy metals[1].
The results revealed that pink salts contain inconsistent and unpredictable levels of nutrients, with significant variations between samples. For instance, iron levels ranged between 0 and 17 mg per 100 grams, while calcium levels varied between 53 and 574 mg per 100 g[1]. More alarmingly, the study found that pink salt samples with higher concentrations of essential nutrients also contained higher levels of heavy metals, including lead, aluminum, cadmium, and arsenic. Some samples contained up to 19 mg per 100 g of aluminum and up to 0.26 mg per 100 g of lead, with one sample exceeding the national contaminant level[1]. This evidence directly contradicts marketing claims positioning pink salt as nutritionally superior to regular salt.
Comparative Analysis of Salt Types and Their Safety Profiles
A broader investigation conducted by Mamavation tested 23 popular salt products for heavy metals and microplastics, providing valuable comparative data across different salt types. This testing revealed that all salt products, regardless of type, contained detectable amounts of various metals, though none at levels requiring warning labels based on standard serving sizes[3].
The prevalence of specific contaminants was striking: 78% of salt products contained aluminum, 100% contained arsenic, 70% contained cadmium, and 96% contained lead. Mercury was the only tested heavy metal not detected in any of the samples[3]. This widespread contamination indicates that the issue extends beyond just pink Himalayan salt to affect virtually all salt products on the market.
When comparing salt types, the investigation categorized products into three tiers based on contamination levels:
Lowest Contamination Salt Products
The safest salt products exhibited significantly lower heavy metal concentrations, with all aluminum levels under 2 ppm, arsenic at 15.27 ppb or less, cadmium at 2.56 ppb or less, no detectable mercury, and lead at 14.99 ppb or less[3]. While specific brand names would be helpful for Australian consumers, the data suggests that certain salt products are substantially safer than others in terms of heavy metal contamination.
Moderate Contamination Salt Products
The “better” category included several Himalayan pink salt products with moderate contamination levels. These had aluminum between 2.154-80.468 ppm, arsenic between 7.39-24.14 ppb, cadmium between non-detect and 0.77 ppb, no mercury, and lead between 45.63-90.25 ppb[3]. The presence of popular Himalayan salt brands in this middle category rather than the lowest contamination group further challenges the perception that these salts are inherently healthier.
Highest Contamination Salt Products
The most contaminated salt products contained significantly higher levels of heavy metals, with aluminum ranging from 29-242 ppm, arsenic from 12.53-82.16 ppb, cadmium up to 7.32 ppb, and lead between 92.56-553.44 ppb[3]. This substantial variation in contamination levels highlights the importance of informed consumer choices.
Salt Regulation and Iodization in Australia
In Australia, salt fortification with iodine is regulated by the Food Standards Code, which requires concentrations of potassium iodate added to salt to be between 25 to 65 milligrams of iodine per kg of salt[4]. This regulation is important because iodine is an essential nutrient, but the technology used to add it to salt can affect overall quality and consistency.
Potassium iodate is the compound most likely to be added to salt by major suppliers to the food industry in Australia and New Zealand. At the maximum permitted concentration (65 mg per kg salt, equivalent to 109.6 mg of potassium iodate per kg salt), there is no difficulty in dissolving the potassium iodate completely in water up to the saturation point of the salt itself[4]. This indicates that properly iodized salt in Australia should have consistent iodine levels when produced by major manufacturers.
The technical documents reveal that there are differences in how iodine compounds are added to salt. Some producers mill potassium iodate to a fine powder before adding it to salt, while others do not necessarily do so, which can affect the distribution of iodine throughout the salt[4]. This technical consideration may impact the overall quality and consistency of iodized salt products.
Recommendations for Choosing Safer Salt Options in Australia
Based on the available research, several recommendations can be made for Australian consumers looking to minimize their exposure to heavy metals from salt:
Consider Non-Pink Salt Alternatives
The evidence clearly indicates that pink Himalayan salts, despite their marketing claims, often contain higher levels of heavy metals compared to some other alternatives[1]. Consumers concerned about heavy metal exposure might want to reconsider using pink salt as their primary salt source.
Look for Established Quality Control Processes
Salt producers with stringent quality control protocols are more likely to deliver consistent products with lower contamination. For instance, Cheetham Salt Limited in Australia has demonstrated excellent quality control specifications for iodized salt over a two-year period, with regular testing of samples[4]. Choosing products from established manufacturers with transparent quality control processes may reduce exposure to contaminants.
Prioritize Refined Salt Products
More refined salt products generally undergo additional processing steps that can remove impurities. While this may also remove some minerals, it typically results in lower heavy metal content. The Mamavation testing showed that some of the lowest contamination products had undergone more extensive refinement[3].
Consider Potential Trade-offs
It’s worth noting that while heavily refined salt products may have lower heavy metal contamination, they might also contain additives or anti-caking agents. Consumers should weigh these factors based on their individual health priorities and concerns.
The Australian Context for Salt Safety
While global research provides valuable insights, the Australian regulatory environment for food safety is robust, with specific standards for contaminants in food products. The Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) sets maximum levels for various contaminants, including heavy metals, in food commodities. However, the variable nature of contamination in salt products suggests that consumers cannot rely solely on regulatory oversight and should make informed choices based on available research.
Thoughts
The perception that pink Himalayan salt is a healthier alternative to regular salt is not supported by current research. In fact, evidence suggests that pink salt may contain higher levels of potentially harmful heavy metals compared to some other options. Australian consumers concerned about heavy metal exposure should consider choosing refined salt products from established manufacturers with transparent quality control processes.
While all salt products appear to contain some level of heavy metal contamination, the significant variation between products indicates that informed consumer choices can substantially reduce exposure to these contaminants. Additionally, properly iodized salt provides essential nutrients under Australian regulations.
More research specific to the Australian market would be valuable, including brand-specific testing and analysis of local salt products. Until such research is available, consumers would be wise to approach health claims about specialty salts with skepticism and prioritize products with lower demonstrated levels of heavy metal contamination.
Sources
[1] Pink salts are NOT healthier for you – Foodwatch https://foodwatch.com.au/blog/healthy-eating-for-wellness/item/pink-salts-are-not-healthier-for-you.html
[2] Tracing the impact of toxic metals | ANSTO https://www.ansto.gov.au/news/tracing-impact-of-toxic-metals
[3] Sea Salt & Himalayan Salt Tested For Heavy Metals Like Lead https://mamavation.com/food/sea-salt-himalayan-salt-heavy-metals-lead.html
[4] [PDF] TECHNOLOGICAL ISSUES WITH SALT BRINE ADDITION OF … https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/sites/default/files/food-standards-code/proposals/Documents/P230_Iodine_Fortification_Attach_9_Technological_Issues.pdf
[5] Researchers find harmful levels of heavy metals in Himalayan salt https://telegrafi.com/en/studiuesit-gjejne-nivele-te-demshme-te-metaleve-te-renda-ne-kripen-e-himalajeve/
[6] How pink salt could be harming your health – 3AW https://www.3aw.com.au/dangerously-high-levels-of-lead-found-in-pink-salt/
[7] Living Valley Organic Australian Lake Salt (Fine) – 1kg https://livingvalleyshop.com.au/products/living-valley-organic-australian-lake-salt-fine-1kg-refill-tub
[8] Australian study questions health claims of Himalayan Pink Salt https://www.lakedeborah.co.uk/blogs/news/australian-study-questions-health-claims-of-pink-salt
[9] Salt use patterns and heavy metal urinary excretion – Frontiers https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/nutrition/articles/10.3389/fnut.2024.1521826/full
[10] An Analysis of the Mineral Composition of Pink Salt Available in … https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7603209/
[11] CHOOSING THE PUREST SALT FOR YOUR FAMILY – Brainstorm Health https://www.brainstormhealth.co.uk/2024/08/5599/
[12] Heavy Metals In Salts – Safety Guide – Holistic Mums https://holisticmums.com.au/heavy-metals-in-salts-safety-guide/
[13] Pink salt health claims salted by Australian study – The New Daily https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/life/health/2020/10/20/pink-salt-health-claims
[14] How much Lead is in salt? Which salt is safest to use for cooking? Is … https://tamararubin.com/2020/10/how-much-lead-is-in-salt-which-salt-is-safest-to-use-for-cooking-is-himalayan-salt-safe/
[15] Gourmet Table Salts: The Mineral Composition Showdown – PMC https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10459412/
[16] Comparing 6 Common Salt Types & Differences in Toxic Content https://crucialfour.com/blogs/blog/a-comparison-of-common-salts-harvesting-methods-microplastic-heavy-metals-content/
[17] [PDF] PRODUCT DESCRIPTION SAXA Iodised Salt is a dried, natur https://superiorfs.com.au/documents/PDF/IOSA750_1.pdf
[18] Toxic heavy metal ions contamination in water and their sustainable … https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-58061-3
[19] [PDF] Studies of Heavy Metal Pollution in Australia with Particular … – Scope https://scope.dge.carnegiescience.edu/SCOPE_31/SCOPE_31_2.08_Chapter13_187-216.pdf
[20] Best Salt WITHOUT heavy metals? : r/blueprint_ – Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/blueprint_/comments/1gdqfih/best_salt_without_heavy_metals/
[21] Iodised salt – Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodised_salt
[22] An analysis of the mineral composition of pink salt available in … https://researchers.mq.edu.au/en/publications/an-analysis-of-the-mineral-composition-of-pink-salt-available-in–
[23] Heavy Metals in Salt: Third-Party Tested Options for Safe Consumption https://www.ruanliving.com/blog/heavy-metals-in-salt-safe-options
[24] Ancient Salts – Cell Squared https://www.cellsquared.com.au/collections/ancient-salts
[25] Iodine – health benefits and how much you need – Healthdirect https://www.healthdirect.gov.au/iodine
[26] Iodine fortification – Food Standards Australia New Zealand https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/consumer/food-fortification/iodine-fortification
[27] [PDF] Iodine Supplementation – NHMRC https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/attachments/publications/new45-statement.pdf
[28] Sea Salt Flakes 250g – Cell Squared https://www.cellsquared.com.au/products/sea-salt-flakes
[29] An Analysis of the Mineral Composition of Pink Salt Available in … https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33086585/
[30] Pure Ocean® Premium Australian Sea Salt https://www.pureoceansalt.com
[31] [PDF] Safety Data Sheet Sodium Chloride (Salt) – Redox https://redox.com/wp-content/sds/3067.pdf
[32] Iodine supplementation – O&G Magazine https://www.ogmagazine.org.au/14/3-14/iodine-supplementation/
[33] Quality – Salt of the Earth https://www.saltoftheearth.com.au/sea-salt/quality/